React Query vs Redux Toolkit Query: Which One is Better?

Introduction

Both React Query and Redux Toolkit Query (RTK Query) are strong tools for managing state and retrieving data in React apps. But they have different functions and perform better in various situations. To decide which is best for your project, let's examine their salient characteristics, distinctions, and applications.

Key Features

RTK Query

·        Because it was created as an extension of Redux Toolkit, it works seamlessly with projects that already use Redux Toolkit.

 

·        Provides background data syncing and automatic caching.

 

• Includes integrated error handling and retry mechanisms
• Provides a querying syntax with support for pagination, sorting, and filtering
• Ideal for projects that require an integrated Redux Toolkit-based state management solution

·        Provides more consistent state updates by controlling data retrieval within the same framework as client state.

React Query

·        A stand-alone library that only uses Redux Toolkit for data fetching and caching

 

• Simplifies data fetching in React applications with a clean and declarative API

·        Provides fine-grained control over cache management and query invalidation.

 

·        Supports several data sources, such as GraphQL and REST.

 

·        Features integrated server-side rendering (SSR) functionality.

 

• More flexible since it does not depend on Redux Toolkit

Key Differences

Feature	RTK Query	React Query
Redux Toolkit Dependency	Integrated with Redux Toolkit	Standalone
API Flexibility	Uses Redux Toolkit slices and store	More declarative and flexible
State Management	Best for managing state alongside data fetching	Focuses solely on remote data fetching
Use Case	Great for managing complex app state alongside data fetching	Best for handling remote server data and caching

Which One Should You Choose?

Use RTK Query if:

• Your project already relies on Redux Toolkit for state management
• You want a built-in solution that integrates seamlessly with Redux Toolkit slices
• Your application requires a unified approach to managing both global state and remote data

Use React Query if:

• You prefer a lightweight, standalone data-fetching solution
• You want more flexibility and finer control over caching and query invalidation
• You want to avoid Redux Toolkit complexity and keep state management separate from data fetching

Can They Be Used Together?

Indeed! Redux Toolkit Query and React Query can be used in tandem. Redux Toolkit Query is a fantastic tool for handling data fetching in Redux-based applications, whereas React Query is perfect for managing distant data synchronization. If both are necessary for your app, it may be ideal to use them together.

Final Verdict

RTK Query is an obvious choice if Redux Toolkit is already a fundamental component of your application. React Query is a preferable option, though, if you're searching for a more straightforward and adaptable method of handling data fetching without the Redux Toolkit. The choice ultimately comes down to the requirements of your project and your architectural tastes.

#ReactQuery #Redux #StateManagement #WebDevelopment #ReactJS #JavaScript #FrontendDevelopment #Coding #RTKQuery #ReactHooks #DevCommunity #TechBlog #ProgrammingTips #technologiesaiblogs